Misplaced Pages

Antisemitism in Soviet mathematics

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Discrimination in the USSR towards Jewish mathematicians
You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Russian. (December 2021) Click for important translation instructions.
  • View a machine-translated version of the Russian article.
  • Machine translation, like DeepL or Google Translate, is a useful starting point for translations, but translators must revise errors as necessary and confirm that the translation is accurate, rather than simply copy-pasting machine-translated text into the English Misplaced Pages.
  • Consider adding a topic to this template: there are already 1,004 articles in the main category, and specifying|topic= will aid in categorization.
  • Do not translate text that appears unreliable or low-quality. If possible, verify the text with references provided in the foreign-language article.
  • You must provide copyright attribution in the edit summary accompanying your translation by providing an interlanguage link to the source of your translation. A model attribution edit summary is Content in this edit is translated from the existing Russian Misplaced Pages article at ]; see its history for attribution.
  • You may also add the template {{Translated|ru|Антисемитизм в советской математике}} to the talk page.
  • For more guidance, see Misplaced Pages:Translation.
Part of a series on
Antisemitism
  • Part of Jewish history and discrimination
    • Definitions
    Geography
    Manifestations
    Antisemitic tropes
    Antisemitic publications
    Persecution
    Antisemitism on the Internet
    Opposition
    Category

    Antisemitism in Soviet mathematics was a manifestation of hostility, prejudice and discrimination in the Soviet Union towards Jews in the scientific and educational environment related to mathematics.

    According to numerous testimonies and facts, from the second half of the 1960s to the beginning of the 1980s, Jews studying or working in the field of mathematics in the USSR were discriminated against when entering universities, postgraduate studies and work, when defending their dissertations, when trying to publish an article or book, when traveling to scientific conferences and abroad.

    Academicians Ivan Vinogradov, Lev Pontryagin and a number of others, who for a long time led and determined policy in Soviet mathematics, were accused by contemporaries of carrying out antisemitic policies. This has caused several international scandals. Pontryagin himself denied these accusations.

    Discrimination became one of the reasons for the mass emigration of Jewish mathematicians from the USSR. Due to possible emigration, Jews in the USSR were often viewed as disloyal citizens, although discrimination preceded emigration, and not vice versa.

    Background

    Antisemitism in the USSR was a continuation of antisemitism in the Russian Empire. Since 1887 in the Russian Empire there was a Jewish quota for students ranging from 3% in Moscow and Saint Petersburg and up to 10% in the Pale of Settlement region. Some educational institutions were generally closed for Jews. Jews were allowed to lecture at universities as a rare exception; it was almost impossible for a Jew to make a scientific career in Russia.

    At the state level, antisemitism emerged in the USSR in the late 1930s and peaked in the late 1940s and early 1950s. During this period, two major openly anti-Jewish trials took place — the case of the Night of the Murdered Poets and the "doctors' plot". In 1944, restrictions were imposed on the admission of Jews to universities. During the anti-cosmopolitan campaign, Jewish students were expelled from universities, and scientists and teachers were fired from their jobs.

    Since 1967, after the Arab-Israeli Six-Day War, anti-Zionist propaganda has sharply intensified in the USSR, often turning into prejudice towards Jews. On 9 March 1968, 99 mathematicians signed a letter [ru] against the illegal forced sending of dissident Alexander Esenin-Volpin to a psychiatric hospital. After that, many who signed the letter were subjected to repression: they were required to refuse to sign the letter, they were kicked out of their jobs, demoted, prohibited from traveling abroad, etc. Gradually, the leadership of Soviet mathematics was changed, and a new antisemitic policy began to be pursued.

    Discrimination against Jewish mathematicians in the USSR

    Discrimination in education

    Historian Semyon Charny, an employee of the Memorial human rights research centre, notes that discrimination was originally inherent in the Soviet education system, but was based on class. A discriminatory system based on ethnicity in order to prevent Jews from entering certain universities emerged in the late 1940s. It was fully formed and operated since the 1960s. The Shorter Jewish Encyclopedia reports that during this period “many faculties of Moscow, Leningrad, Kiev and other universities, the Moscow Engineering Physics Institute, the Moscow Physics and Technology Institute were completely or partially closed to Jews. Many academic institutions stopped hiring Jews.” Lyudmila Alexeyeva, a human rights activist and member of the Moscow Helsinki Group, noted that "constraint in access to education is the most sensitive of the discriminatory measures against Jews, since the desire to educate children is one of the best preserved traditions in Jewish families."

    One of the most scandalous areas of this discrimination was the massive denial of admission to the MSU Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics for applicants of Jewish origin. Israeli-Swiss author and journalist George Szpiro calls the current rector of Moscow State University Viktor Sadovnichiy (at that time he supervised the work of admissions committees), the dean of the MSU Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics Oleg Lupanov, as well as professor and senior examiner Alexander Mishchenko as the main conductors of the discriminatory policy at the MSU Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics. Russian-French mathematician Alexander Shen [ru] adds to this list a number of members of the selection committee. Leading researcher of the Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics Vladimir Tkachuk wrote about the mass discrimination of Jews in the textbook "Mathematics for an applicant". A similar system operated at the Bauman Moscow State Technical University and some other prestigious universities.

    George Szpiro wrote:

    The hurdles were raised in the oral exam. Unwanted candidates were given “killer questions” that required difficult reasoning and long computations. Some questions were impossible to solve, were stated in an ambiguous way, or had no correct answer. They were not designed to test a candidate’s skill but meant to weed out “undesirables”.

    There were significantly fewer Jews admitted to the Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics of Moscow State University in 1978 than under the conditions of the Jewish quota of the Russian Empire. That year, 21 graduates of one of the Moscow mathematical schools entered the faculty, including 14 Russians and 7 Jews. All 14 Russians were accepted, out of 7 Jews — only 1 (he received the 1st prize at the International Mathematical Olympiad and for 3 years in a row received the 1st prize at the All-Union Olympiads). Among the rejected Jews, two were multiple winners of the Moscow Olympiad [ru].

    Mathematician and dissident Valery Senderov spoke about the methods by which the administration of the Mechanics and Mathematics Department did not allow Jewish applicants to enter the university. So, the most talented of Jewish students, who were difficult to weed out in other ways, were asked to solve the most complex mathematical problems of the All-Union and international mathematical Olympiads [ru] as problems for entrance exams, which was directly prohibited by the instructions of the USSR Ministry of Higher Education. Special problems were also designed, which had a formal solution within the framework of the school curriculum, but it was impossible to solve them in a reasonable time. In the oral examinations, questions were asked that went far beyond the scope of the school curriculum. Sometimes during oral examinations Jewish applicants were gathered into separate groups, and the auditoriums where they took the exams were called "gas chambers" (Russian: газовые камеры). According to Mikhail Shifman, professor at the Institute of Theoretical Physics at the University of Minnesota, “only those Jewish applicants who, for special reasons, were not included in these groups, for example, the children of professors, academicians or other "necessary" people, could enroll" in the Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics at Moscow State University.

    Academician Igor Shafarevich, speaking about the representation of different nationalities in prestigious areas, wrote about these exams:

    On the other hand, it must be said by what means these problems were solved until recently - for example, in mathematics. Of course, I must say about them - they were monstrous. During the exams there was a struggle, a war with teenagers, almost children. They were asked meaningless or ambiguous questions that were confusing. This had a destructive effect on their psychology, on the psychology of them and other adolescents, who saw that applicants for exams were divided into groups. When they saw, for example, that from one audience they come out with solid twos, and another group with fours and fives. A class of such examiners was created. These people, of course, would be ready for other similar actions.

    Academician Andrei Sakharov also commented on this discrimination. He wrote that similar methods were used not only against Jewish applicants, but also against the children of dissidents.

    The problems themselves, offered to Jewish applicants for entrance exams at the Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics of Moscow State University, gained fame and became the subject of discussion in the international scientific community.

    See also

    References

    1. ^ "Хроника текущих событий — Выпуск 51" [Chronicle of Current Events — Issue 51]. Memorial (society). 1978-12-01. Archived from the original on 2021-02-24.
    2. ^ Kolata, Gina Bari (1978-12-15). "Anti-Semitism Alleged in Soviet Mathematics". Science. 202 (4373): 1167–1170. Bibcode:1978Sci...202.1167B. doi:10.1126/science.202.4373.1167. PMID 17735390.
    3. Freiman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay. Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. p. 96. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    4. ^ Tsalenko, Mikhail (2011). "Calenko1". berkovich-zametki.com (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    5. Katok, Anatole (2008). "Moscow dynamics seminars of the Nineteen seventies and the early career of Yasha Pesin". Discrete & Continuous Dynamical Systems. 22 (1&2): 1–22. doi:10.3934/dcds.2008.22.1.
    6. Novikov, Sergei (1999). "Рохлин (из серии очерков "Математики за кулисами социализма")" [Rokhlin (from a series of essays "Mathematics behind the scenes of socialism")]. mccme.ru (in Russian).
    7. Novikov, Sergei. "Мои истории" [My stories] (PDF). mi.ras.ru (in Russian). p. 33.
    8. Tikhomirov, Vladimir (2004). "О Леониде Витальевиче Канторовиче" [About Leonid Vitalievich Kantorovich]. vivovoco.astronet.ru (in Russian). Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    9. Katok, Anatole (2008). "Moscow dynamics seminars of the Nineteen seventies and the early career of Yasha Pesin". Discrete & Continuous Dynamical Systems. 22 (1&2): 9. doi:10.3934/dcds.2008.22.1.
    10. ^ Szpiro, George (2007). "Notices of the American Mathematical Society" (PDF). American Mathematical Society. p. 1326. ISSN 0002-9920.
    11. Tsirel, Sergey (2008). "Сталинская урбанизация и упадок советской науки" [Stalinist urbanization and the decline of Soviet science] (PDF). Higher School of Economics (in Russian). p. 118.
    12. Pontryagin, Lev (1998). Zhizneopisanie Lʹva Semenovicha Pontri︠a︡gina, matematika, sostavlennoe im samim : rozhdenii︠a︡ 1908, g. Moskva [Biography of L. S. Pontryagin, mathematician, compiled by himself] (in Russian). Moskva: IChP "Prima V". p. 302. ISBN 5-85240-062-9. OCLC 49502078.
    13. Feinberg, Evgenii. "Неизбрание в Академию наук CCCР Гельфанда было позором" [Gelfand's failure to be elected to the Academy of Sciences of the USSR was a shame]. peoples.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    14. Bernstein, Jared (1982-01-05). "Emigrant Mathematicians Fault Soviet Anti-Semitism | News | The Harvard Crimson". The Harvard Crimson. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    15. ^ Kolata, Gina Bari (1978-12-15). "Anti-Semitism Alleged in Soviet Mathematics". Science. 202 (4373): 1170. Bibcode:1978Sci...202.1167B. doi:10.1126/science.202.4373.1167. PMID 17735390.
    16. Podhoretz, Norman (1985). "Евреи в современном мире" [Jews in the modern world] (PDF). vtoraya-literatura.com (in Russian). p. 114.
    17. "процентная норма" [Jewish quota]. Shorter Jewish Encyclopedia (in Russian). 1992. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    18. Safonov, Aleksandr; Naumov, I (2013). "Ограничение прав еврейского населения Российской империи в доступе к высшему образованию в конце XIX - начале XX в." [Restriction of the rights of the Jewish population of the Russian Empire in access to higher education in the late 19th - early 20th centuries]. Higher School of Economics (in Russian) (3). ISSN 2221-3287.
    19. "Россия. Евреи в русской культуре и науке и в российской общественно-политической жизни (до 1917 г.)" [Russia. Jews in Russian culture and science and in Russian social and political life (until 1917)]. Shorter Jewish Encyclopedia (in Russian). 1994. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    20. Kostyrchenko, Gennady (2003). Taĭnai︠a︡ politika Stalina : vlastʹ i antisemitism [Stalin's Secret Politics: Power and Anti-Semitism] (in Russian). Moskva. pp. 703–709. ISBN 5-7133-1071-X. OCLC 48646383. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
    21. Batygin, Gennady; Deviatko, Inna (1993). "Еврейский вопрос: хроника сороковых годов" [The Jewish Question: A Chronicle of the Forties]. Russian Academy of Sciences (in Russian). p. 65.
    22. ^ Gubailovsky, Vladimir; Kostinsky, Alexander (2005-01-05). "Дискриминации при поступлении в высшие учебные заведения Советского Союза" [Discrimination in admission to higher educational institutions of the Soviet Union]. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    23. Kostyrchenko, Gennady (2003). Taĭnai︠a︡ politika Stalina : vlastʹ i antisemitism [Stalin's Secret Politics: Power and Anti-Semitism] (in Russian). Moskva. pp. 555–609. ISBN 5-7133-1071-X. OCLC 48646383. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
    24. "Антисемитизм в 1970–80-е гг" [Antisemitism in the 1970s and 1980s]. Shorter Jewish Encyclopedia (in Russian). 1992. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    25. "Внесудебные политические репрессии 1968 года" [Extrajudicial political repression of 1968]. Memorial (society) (in Russian). Archived from the original on 2012-02-17. Retrieved 2021-12-25.
    26. Petrenko-Podyapolskaya, Maria (2001). "Письмо 99-ти" [Letter of 99]. Memorial (society) (in Russian).
    27. Tsinman, Leonid (2014-09-20). "Похождения рядового подписанта - после "письма 99 математиков"" [The adventures of an ordinary signatory - after the “letter of 99 mathematicians”]. snob.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    28. Katok, Anatole (2008). "Moscow dynamics seminars of the Nineteen seventies and the early career of Yasha Pesin". Discrete & Continuous Dynamical Systems. 22 (1&2): 14. doi:10.3934/dcds.2008.22.1.
    29. Tsalenko, Mikhail (2013). "Михаил Цаленко. Взгляд назад невидящих глаз" [Mikhail Tsalenko. A look back from unseeing eyes]. 7iskusstv.com (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    30. ^ Ilyashenko, Yulij (2009-07-28). ""Черное 20-летие" мехмата МГУ" ["Black 20th Anniversary" of the Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics of Moscow State University]. polit.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    31. ^ Shen, Alexander. "Entrance Examinations to the Mekh-mat" (PDF). 3038.org (in Russian).
    32. Freiman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay. Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. p. 86. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    33. ^ Novikov, Sergei (2013-03-20). "Видение математики" [Vision of mathematics]. polit.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    34. ^ Freiman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay (in Russian). Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. p. 17. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    35. "Советский Союз. Евреи в Советском Союзе в 1967–85 гг" [Soviet Union. Jews in the Soviet Union 1967-85]. Shorter Jewish Encyclopedia (in Russian). 1996. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    36. ^ Alexeyeva, Lyudmila (1992). Istorii︠a︡ inakomyslii︠a︡ v SSSR : noveĭshiĭ period [History of Dissent in the USSR: The Newest Period] (in Russian). Vilʹni︠u︡s: Vestʹ. p. 123. OCLC 28404243.
    37. ^ Kolata, Gina Bari (1978-12-15). "Anti-Semitism Alleged in Soviet Mathematics". Science. 202 (4373): 1169. Bibcode:1978Sci...202.1167B. doi:10.1126/science.202.4373.1167. PMID 17735390.
    38. Graham, Loren R. (1984). "Science and Computers in Soviet Society". Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science. 35 (3): 124–134. doi:10.2307/1174122. ISSN 0065-0684. JSTOR 1174122.
    39. Vershik, Anatoly (2013-02-25). "Глазами математика" [Through the eyes of a mathematician]. polit.ru. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    40. ^ Shifman, Mikhail; Kanevsky, Boris; Sonin, Konstantin (2012-12-24). "Сендеров — борец с интеллектуальным геноцидом" [Senderov is a fighter against intellectual genocide]. trv-science.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    41. Tsfasman, Mikhail (2009-01-30). "Судьбы математики в России" [The fate of mathematics in Russia]. polit.ru. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    42. Reiter, Svetlana (2012-11-21). "Ученые большого города. Михаил Цфасман" [Scientists of the big city. Mikhail Tsfasman]. bg.ru. Archived from the original on 2014-01-08. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
    43. Tkachuk, Vladimir (2007). Математика абитуриенту [Mathematics for an applicant] (in Russian). Library Genesis. МЦНМО. p. 818. ISBN 978-5-94057-298-5.
    44. Saul, Mark. "Kerosinka: An Episode in the History of Soviet Mathematics" (PDF). American Mathematical Society.
    45. Israel Gohberg and friends : on the occasion of his 80th birthday. I. Gohberg, H. Bart, Thomas Hempfling, M. A. Kaashoek. Basel: Birkhäuser. 2008. ISBN 978-3-7643-8734-1. OCLC 288569768.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: others (link)
    46. Szpiro, George (2007). Notices of the American Mathematical Society (PDF). Vol. 54. American Mathematical Society. p. 1327.
    47. Freiman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay. Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. p. 13. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    48. Toptygo, A (1992). "Игорь Шафаревич и проблемы дуалистического сознания" [Igor Shafarevich and the problems of dualistic consciousness]. panorama.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-25.
    49. Entova, Asya (2008-12-18). "Хроники Иерусалима. Ася Энтова. Такая знакомая дискриминация" [Chronicles of Jerusalem. Asya Entova. Such familiar discrimination]. gazeta.rjews.net (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-12-25.
    50. Rolnik, Guy (2008-05-18). "Google Co-founder: My Family Left Russia Because of anti-Semitism". Haaretz. Retrieved 2021-12-25.
    51. Freiman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay. Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. pp. 21–27. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    52. Shafarevich, Igor (1991). Estʹ li u Rossii budushchee? : publit︠s︡istika [Does Russia have a future?] (in Russian). Moskva: Sov. pisatelʹ. pp. 536–537. ISBN 5-265-01844-1. OCLC 25747238.
    53. Freiman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay. Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. p. 97. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    54. Khovanova, Tanyana; Radul, Alexey (2011-10-18). "Jewish Problems". arXiv:1110.1556 .
    55. Vardi, Ilan (2000). "Mekh-mat entrance examinations problems". preprints.ihes.fr. Archived from the original on 2013-10-05.
    56. Freĭman, Gregory (1980). It seems I am a Jew : a Samizdat essay. Melvyn B. Nathanson. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. pp. 14–15. ISBN 0-8093-0962-9. OCLC 5946582.
    Categories: